Saturday, January 24, 2009
Developmental Action Inquiry
From Developmental Action Inquiry: A Distinct Integral Theory That Actually Integrates
Developmental Theory, Practice and Research, by Torbet et. al. Paper presented to the Integral Theory in Academia Conference 2008.
Monday, September 22, 2008
Play as an Integral Life Practice
I really enjoyed reading the recent article by Gwen Gordon and Sean Esbjorn-Hargens called Integral Play: An exploration of the playground and the evolution of the player.
Their developmental hypothesis on the evolution of the player rings in loud resonance with my experience of growing through play-forms. I feel it quite accurately accounts/describes notions of play that I have discarded and longed for at different points on my road.
The hypothesis also made me ponder how my relationship to experiences at my edge of development completely transform when framed as play. In particular, I can take spiritual practice so seriously at times that it becomes a form of burden and toil. Seeing Gwen and Sean frame the exploratory nature of practice as a form of play brings a bright new constellation to my relationship with it.
Here's a wonderful excerpt from the paper:
"The Eight Play Selves are based on Susanne Cook-Greuter's and William Torbert's full spectrum Action-Inquiry research on postautonomous ego development. Their research represents the most sophisticated and extensive full-spectrum (prepersonal, personal, postpersonal, and post- postpersonal) research available… Each play self has a unique way of relating to itself, other playmates, and the playground. In brief:
- The impulsive self is a Magical Player who connects with the cosmos by balancing dichotomous forces such as good and evil. They have a strong concern for creating safety and satisfying basic needs. The Magical Player has a sense of unlimited power combined with superstitious and magical notions. Their play is often highly repetitive. They view other people primarily as a source of self-gratification and feel confused and anxious by the complexity of the world.
- The self-protective self is an Aggressive Player who is self-serving. Their play often takes the form of heroic acts. They identify the self in terms of its will, ideas, and wishes. Self- preservation is central. They project all their feelings and rarely self-reflect. They think globally with many judgments and simple ideas. They see other people as competitors for space, goods, and dominance and have little capacity for insight into self and others. They often cross other's boundaries in a crusade of low trust and hyper-vigilance. They experience the world as a dangerous place filled with perilous risk.
- The conformist self is an Ordered Player who is rule-oriented and concerned with group membership. They define themselves through others. They have no stable and clear boundaries between the self and the group. Projection and introjection are their common defenses. They suppress negative feelings and overemphasize positive ones. They have a strong need to be accepted and to reject those who do not conform to the group. They view their world through a concrete-literal lens.
- The conscientious self is a Status Player who is defined by their orientation toward linear causality, objective (third-person) thinking, and a newly emerging separate self-identity, which lends itself to competition for status. The self has greater independence and confidence. They have an interest in their emotional life, though rationality is emphasized. They associate with others with similar goals and desires in life. They are drawn to achievement and accomplishing goals by being concise, efficient, and effective. They have a genuine interest in others, independent of their own needs and values. The world is experienced as predictable and measurable.
- The individualistic self is a Sensitive Player who emphasizes connectivity between people, especially by sharing experiences, acknowledging contextual aspects of play (e.g., gender, class, race), and systemic dynamics of reality. They are aware of the observer and multiple viewpoints. They abandon objectivity and logic in favor of more holistic and organismic approaches. They value feelings and express them. They are aware of the conditioning dynamics of culture and context. They have the capacity to empathize with others and take their perspective. They understand their world is filled with diverse perspectives and competing truth claims.
- The autonomous self is a Complex Player who welcomes chaos and multiple variables in service of self-development. The Complex Player understands the self as embedded in many contexts and dimensions. They accept many aspects of self through a complex psychology that integrates shadow material. They tolerate others in spite of their negative traits and differences of opinions or values. They experience their world as multidimensional with overlapping contexts and systems.
- The construct-aware self is a Dynamic Player who integrates multimodal and multidimensional elements across contexts in service of humanity. They are aware of the subtle ways the ego filters experience. The Dynamic Player recognizes paradox and the limits of "mapping." They desire to work through their own limits and blind spots and increase their capacity to witness themselves in the moment. They understand others in developmental terms and encounter them without judgment. They have a profound understanding of other's complex and dynamic personalities. They experience the world as a place full of potential and paradox.
- The ego-aware self is a Unitive Player who is a transparent manifestation of Being, completely spontaneous and open. They have stable access to transpersonal realities such as the capacity to witness all experience and keep their boundaries open. They view others as manifestations of Being. They experience the world as an immanent expression of timeless Spirit (see figure 6 below)".
Fig 6
Ctr. Of Identity | Play Selves | Style of Play | Examples |
Pneumacentric | Unitive Player Play as Lila | Spontaneous, Witnessing, highly creative, Original, and open | Identification with the play of the world. Improv. at psychospiritual levels, Crazy wisdom, Tantra, and playing with luminosity. Unites determinisitic and free, structured and open chaos and order |
Kosmocenttric | Dynamic Player Play as transformative | Multimodal and multidimensional | Improvisation with transformation, Meditation, holotropic breathwork, inquiry |
Worldcentric | Complex Player Play as chaos | Fast and unpredictable | Improvisation with the world, improv. Movement and theater, multidimensional simulations, virtual reality |
Worldcentric | Sensitive Player Play as cooperation | Connecting and sharing | Name games, ropes courses, New Games, team building exercises |
Sociocentric | Status Player Play as competitions | Winning and Losing | Video games, gambling, poker, competitive sports, games at fairs and carnivals, ropes courses (trans.) |
Ethnocentric | Ordered Player Play as structure | Following the rules | Board games, collections, hobbies, card games, intellectual games |
Egocentric | Aggressive Player Play as conquest | Acts of heroism | Survivor, war games, chicken, drinking games, boxing/fights |
Egocentric | Magical Player Play as connection to cosmos | Balancing good and evil | Dungeons and Dragons, fantasy games, divination: Runes, Tarot, magic tricks, charms, rituals |
Wednesday, May 21, 2008
Present Centred
... and she writes a great turn of phrase.
This is a recent post which really got me:
"There are fingernail marks in the tight grip I have on the words of a beautiful angel called Ana, who a month ago told me to stop doubting the validity of my perceptions. It's healthy to doubt the knowledge that I have about those perceptions, but don't doubt the seeing".
http://calmclarity.blogspot.com/2008/05/present-centred.html
Sunday, May 4, 2008
Salon.com Interview with Ken Wilber

Watch out for Steve Paulson's vocal shift toward the end of the interview where he starts twigging that Wilber may be on to something liberating and gets all acquisitive. It's a terribly amusing turn, and I dare say, a very familiar one for me.
You Are The River: An Interview with Ken Wilber
By Steve Paulson April 28, 2008
Ken Wilber may be the most important living philosopher you've never heard of. He's written dozens of books but you'd be hard-pressed to find his name in a mainstream magazine. Still, Wilber has a passionate - almost cultlike - following in certain circles, as well as some famous fans. Bill Clinton and Al Gore have praised Wilber's books. Deepak Chopra calls him "one of the most important pioneers in the field of consciousness." And the Wachowski Brothers asked Wilber, along with Cornel West, to record the commentary for the DVDs of their "Matrix" movies.
A remarkable autodidact, Wilber's books range across entire fields of knowledge, from quantum physics to developmental psychology to the history of religion. He's steeped in the world's esoteric traditions, such as Mahayana Buddhism, Vedantic Hinduism, Sufism and Christian mysticism. Wilber also practices what he preaches, sometimes meditating for hours at a stretch. His "integral philosophy," along with the Integral Institute he's founded, hold out the promise that we can understand mystical experience without lapsing into New Age mush.
Read full article: Here
Q: But somewhere down the road—50 years from now, 500 years from now—once neuroscience becomes much more advanced, will scientists be able to pinpoint where [our] values and thoughts come from?
Thursday, January 10, 2008
Integral Methodological Pluralism
When I was a boy, I remember a moment of exhilaration after a science class when I realised that all scientific 'truth' is merely repeatable hypothesis rather than a given absolutes. It was at a time when I was developing the first stages of my cognitive autonomy, and I was so deeply struck with the arguably premature realisation that I would never truly 'know' anything again. Ontological relativism at age 10... prodigy, huh?! ;-)
After that stunning realisation, I commenced a vigorous campaign to uncover the other spheres of my boyhood awareness (which was really probably just my semantic maps, rather than some premature claim to transpersonal awareness or witness consciousness) to which this relativity could apply. It was stunning! It turned out that nothing could be known without first setting the injunctive scope of inquiry. I felt so free, and so deeply fascinated by this suddenly mysterious place I'd been thrusted into. Epistemological relativity at age 11... Doogie Howser, is that you? ;-)
I was so very lucky to have the cognitive makings of an existential crisis while I was still comprehensively under my family's wing. [muffled coughs masking calls of "wanker!" are heard from the four corners of the earth]... OK, OK, just fucking with you. They were the makings of a postmodern thought process but certainly clumsy first cuts, and from a partially scientistic frame. It certainly wasn't a realisation that all is Always Already.
Anyhoo... I never developed a language to explain my thinking, with every clumsy attempt just digging me further and further into the kook's ditch. Not a fun place for a young tucker. It remained a secret realisation that informed me for years, until the worst happened...
... I got lured into a regressive cycle. Emotional pain around work and relationship incompatabilities left me clinging to an absolutistic worldview as refuge from the dark side of relativism - the difficulty in commanding agreement. In that dark hole, I wasn't able to resolve the mind that had so lucidly living with pluralism for years, with this seemingly foreign need for givens and ultimate truths (in the relative domain). It was nonsense classification neurosis, and with no workable map to chart this far deeper aperspectival territory.
So I read books on mindfulness, Zen, nature mysticism, western psychology and psychotherapy, philosophy, the list goes on, in a mindless search for the private secret that'd hidden itself even from me.
When I devoured Ken's work on IMP I had a thousand kenshos... and I felt forever bolstered in my selfhood. You know the thing, where someone else makes seemingly legitimate what you already know simply because it's published thought! No that ain't fair, it's stunningly argued stuff, and precisely the depth of theoria which my years of IMP practice needed to be complimented with.
There's more than one benefit: learning the historical philosophical imperative for IMP and Integral Post-Metaphysics isn't just the most powerful elucidation of the structral neccessities for the support and flowering of an aperspectival worldview... I also get to be (sorta) right!*... and that makes me feel very safely myself again.
Don't ignore IMP. It's critical stuff. I want to write more about the things I've been noticing from my IMP readings. Get on my case if I don't do it soon.
L.
* within the Always Already quadratic paradigmatic limits of IMP, of course ;-p