Reflections on the Etiology, Pathogenesis and Diagnostic Reassignment of Gambling Dysfunctions in the DSM-V
Luke Fullagar
RMIT University
Academic debate has not reached a universally accepted conclusion on the etiology and pathology of dysfunctionalgambling. Current theory and empirical research remains uncertain on whether dysfunctional gambling should most parsimoniously be considered a behavioral addiction, an obsessive-compulsive or a disorder of impulse control (APA, 2010). This poses difficulties for both treatment development and diagnosis. Moreover, contemporary research has demonstrated that dysfunctional gambling may not form one disorder arising in a homogenous population, but may instead be more accurately explained as a heterogenous group of populations differentiated in etiology, pathogenesis and severity, despite the display of similar phenomenological features (Blaszczynski & Nower, 2002).
The history of the Diagnostic and Statistical Manual's (DSM) treatment of dysfunctional gambling highlights both the uncertiainty which has pervaded classification, and the development over time in understanding its complex of contributory factors. Based on significantly limited research (Blaszcynski, 2005; Rodda, Lubman & Latage, 2012), a diagnosis of Pathological Gambling was originally included in the DSM-III as a disorder of impulse control. Remodeling of criteria in the DSM-III-R was similarly undertaken with minimal recourse to empirical research (Blaszcynski, 2005) and based on substance abuse characterisations which included items of preoccupation, tolerance, withdrawal and efforts to minimise or eliminate gambling (APS, 2010; Rodda, Lubman & Latage, 2012). This model largely endured in the DSM-IV and is currently the dominant theoretical paradigm (Blaszczynski & Nower, 2002; National Research Council, 1999). However, a line of developing research on gambling uses for mood regulation (e.g. dissociation) and not impulse control (Anderson & Brown, 1984; Jacobs, 1986) was recognised by the addition of a new item 'gambling as a means of escape'. Important also was Rosenthal's (1989) suggestion in the DSM-IV review process that criteria should account for the progressive nature of dysfunctional gambling, and distinguish between pathological and non-pathological variants.
Indeed, in the 30 years since the first inclusion of gambling in the DSM, myriad course identifiers and predictive risk factors associated with dysfunctional gambling have been demonstrated, including: access, impulsivity, biological vulnerabilities, behavioural conditioning, emotional-regulation issues, family history, peer group influences and pre-existing psychopathology (Blaszczynski & Nower, 2007; Brewer, Grant, & Potenza, 2008; Toneatto & Nguyen, 2007). In recent times, a number of multifactorial integrated biopsychosocial models have been advanced in an attempt to coherently assimilate these research findings (APS, 2010). Chief among these is the Pathways Model (Blaszczynski & Nower, 2007) which advances three subtypes differentiated on pathogenesis and increasing severity: (1) behaviourally-conditioned gamblers affected primarily by access, conditioning and cognitive processes; (2) emotionally-vulnerable gamblers for whom behavioral conditioning and erroneous cognitions are intensified by extant psychopatholgy including prior emotional and family disturbances, poor coping skills, low-self esteem, and social isolation, and for whom gambling is also a strategy for mood regulation (e.g. dissociation) and induction (e.g. arousal); and (3) impulsive anti-social problem gamblers for whom preexisting psychopatholgy, genetic and neurochemical factors interact to intensify impulsivity and need for stimulation (Blaszczynski & Nower, 2002; APA, 2010; Blaszczynski & Nower, 2007).
However, despite this growing evidence of a complex heterogeneous set of circumstances, it is proposed that the DSM Pathological Gambling diagnosis be reclassified as a one-dimensional behavioral addiction labeled DisorderedGambling in the DSM-V. Some support exists for an addiction model. Clinical and epidemiological studies demonstrate high comorbidity with substance abuse (Petry, 2005). Problem gamblers also present with excessive preoccupation and urges to gamble despite negative consequences, difficulty with reduction and cessation (cf. Blaszczynski & Nower, 2002), and symptoms of withdrawal and tolerance (XXX; APA, 2010).
However, this model has also drawn significant critique. Substances, unlike gambling, directly reinforce cognitive and neurological processes that adapt and develop dependence. Studies observing boredom in participants engaging in moneyless simulated gambling are used as evidence that the arousal to gamble is associated with anticipated wins not the consequence of the direct act itself (Blaszczynski, 2005). Moreover, it is argued that the chasing behaviour witnessed in dysfunctional gamblers is wrongly paralleled with dose tolerance in substance abuse, and better understood as at attempt to recoup lost money (Blaszczynski & Nower, 2002). Furthermore, evidence that dysfunctional gambling is often motivated by a range of persistent erroneous and irrational beliefs which disregard logical probability and mutual independence of chance events despite direct and experiential evidence to the contrary (APA, 2010), is used to mount the argument that symptoms of dependence in dysfunctional gambling are of a cognitive rather than addictive nature (Blaszczynski, 2005).
In light of the above, it appears that a one-dimensional behavioral addiction model suggested for the DSM-V is unreflective of the evidence for a heterogenous condition of varying etiology, pathogenesis and severity, and accordingly a premature conclusion on the matter of dysfunctional gambling. While some arguments have been leveled that an addictions model may result in a practical increase in treatment within a professional and lay culture acquainted with the structure of addictions-modelling for other disorders (e.g. Petry, 2006; Potenza, 2006), the potential risks of unwarranted and incorrect stigmatization, slippery-slope arguments for restriction of other social freedoms, and the evidence for variant forms of gambling dysfunction lead to a conclusion that these positives are not outweighed by their disadvantages.
References
Anderson, G., & Brown, R. I. F. (1984). Real and laboratory gambling: Sensation-seeking and arousal. British Journal of Psychology, 75, 401-410.
APS Australian Psychological Society - Gambling Working Group. (2010). Special Report: The Psychology of Gambling. InPsych, 6, 1-15.
Blaszczynski, A. (2005). To formulate gambling policies on the premise that problem gambling is an addiction may be premature. Addiction, 100(9), 1230-1232.
Blaszczynski, A., & Nower, L. (2002). A pathways model of problem and pathological gambling. Addiction, 97, 487-499.
Blaszczynski, A., & Nower, L. (2007). Etiological processes. In G. Smith, D. Hodgins, & R. Williams (Eds.), Research and measurement issues in gambling studies. Elsevier: Toronto. pp.317-338.
Brewer, J. A., Grant, J. E., & Potenza, M.N. (2008). The treatment of pathological gambling. Addictive Disorders Treatment, 7, 1-13.
Jacobs, D. F. (1986). A general theory of addictions: A new theoretical model. Journal of Gambling Behavior, 2, 15-31.
National Research Council (1999). Pathological gambling: A critical review. Washington D.C.: National Academy Press.
Rodda, S. N., Lubman, D. I., & Latage, K. (2012) Problem gambling; aetiology, identification and management. Australian Family Practice, in press.
Petry, N. M. (2005). Pathological gambling: Etiology, comorbidity and treatment. Washington D.C.: American Psychological Association.
Petry, N. (2006). Should the scope of addictive behaviors be broadened to include pathological gambling? Addiction, 101, 152-160.
Potenza, M. (2007). Should addictive disorders include non-substance-related conditions? Addiction, 101,142-151
Rosenthal, R. J. (1989). Pathological gambling and problem gambling. Problems of definition and
diagnosis. In H.J. Shaffer, S. Stein, B. Gambino, and T.N. Cummings, (Eds.), Compulsive gambling: theory, research, and practice. MA, England. Lexington. pp.101-125.
Toneatto, T., & Nguyen, L. (2007). Individual Characteristics and Problem Gambling Behavior. In G.
Smith, D. Hodgins & R. Williams (Eds). Research and measurement issues in gambling studies, Sydney: Elsevier. pp. 92-103. Toneatto, T. & Gunaratne, C. (2009). Does the treatment of cognitive distortions improve clinical outcomes for problem gambling? Journal of contemporary psychotherapy, 39, 221-229.
O'Brien, C. (2011). Addiction and dependence in DSM-V. Addiction. 106(5), 866-867.
No comments:
Post a Comment