Monday, December 19, 2011

Attachment and Narcissistic Vulnerability


I continue to research the depths of the attachment literature in the process of retrieval of my nervous system from the difficulties of interconnection. It just goes all the way down! So much excellent research, and all of which reads like treatises on our liberation.

One interesting article I recently read by attachment researcher M. Carole Pistole pointed out the links between attachment insecurities and one's unintegrated self as a personal narcissistic vulnerability. This paper is just wonderful, as it points out how the ego-insecurities which typify either active or echo narcissistic defences in *everyone's* ego complexes link so elegantly with the Me OK? You OK? dynamics of one's internal working models of attachment.

One's self-esteem is linked fundamentally to their narcissistic vulnerability to self. As introduced by Freud, the term narcissism has been used to describe a variety of clinical phenomena, including the libidinal investment of the self (Moore & Fine, 1990; Sandier, Person, & Fonagy, 1991). In current usage, the term narcissism, despite theoretical differences between authors, is often used in the context of self-esteem and refers to an aspect of personality, (i.e., of ego organization) that manifests in both healthy and pathological ways (Blanck & Blanck, 1979; Kernberg, 1985; Kohut & Wolf, 1978; Moore & Fine, 1990; Sandier et al, 1991). It is related to the cognitive-affective patterning or structuring of the intrapsychic self (Blanck & Blanck, 1979; Kernberg, 1985; Kohut & Wolf, 1978). With a well-patterned or solid intrapsychic structure, the person is able to (a) soothe and comfort self (i.e., regulate esteem internally; Baker & Baker, 1987), (b) sustain goals and relationships (Patton & Robbins, 1982), and (c) value both self and significant others (i.e., there is an even distribution of self-esteem and other-esteem; Blanck & Blanck, 1979; Moore & Fine, 1990). If, however, the self-structure is less patterned or more nondifferentiated, positive valuing of the self and management of esteem functions depend more on others' behaving in ways that support the self— that is, provide valuing, confirming, or comforting functions (Baker & Baker, 1987; Patton & Robbins, 1982). With a more fragile self-structure, the person has more difficulty maintaining an inner sense of comfort and esteem and so is more easily wounded or hurt (i.e., more narcissistically vulnerable).

The term narcissism has been colloquially used in all kinds of pejorative manners, and this malignant appropriation is a genuine shame IMO, as narcissistic vulnerability as well as healthy libidinal investments which promote healthy narcissistic defences are all part of the ebb and flow of all our personal processes. We all move through that initial position (see Klein in particular) and nobody gets out of there without appeal to some degree of narcissistic vulnerability in one or more contexts. Moreover, the further I go into the literature, the more I see that the internalised projective nature of the colloquial understanding of narcissistic elements typically bolsters whichever insecure position is viewing its alternate - thus, the avoiding will avoid their own narcissistic undeveloped self-object characterised by a negative model of others by projecting this disowned self defence on to the other ("You are not OK (extroverted), I am not OK (suppressed)" (fearful avoidant), or "You are not OK (extroverted) and I am OK" (dismissive avoidant), and then reconstruct a projective narrative about the other to fill the gaps of the shameful vulnerability ("She's so controlling", "He's so ambivalent"). Similarly, the preoccupied will avoid their own narcissistic undeveloped self-object characterised by a negative model of self and a positive model of other by projecting this disowned self love onto the other ("You're OK and I'm not OK"), and then reconstruct a projective narrative to shield shame ("She's so emotionally incompetent", "He's so cold") - what Pickering calls the Narcissism of Echo (which can also include the fearful avoidant position as well, as a narcissistic working model of other.



These working models of self and other, and most importantly, their base in the micro-affective actions and reactions of our nervous systems (all stuff that happens preverbally - see Schore) are the core mechanics of our identities. They govern self-esteem, vulnerability, positive affect, partner seeking, activity choices (e.g. career) and the self in a whole gamut of other circumstances (see the enormous survey of research in all these situations and more in Attachment in Adulthood: Structure, Dynamics, and Change by Mikulincer and Shaver).

Although attachment and narcissism share some theoretical components, they target separate phenomena. Both theories involve cognitive-affective patterning, address affect regulation, and can accommodate healthy as well as pathological development and functioning (see Armstrong & Roth, 1989; Belsky & Nezworski, 1988; Bowlby, 1988; West & Sheldon, 1988). Attachment, however, addresses the person's "need for proximity, care, and security from another who can be experienced as separate from the self (Silverman, 1991, p. 183). Although Bowlby (1988) proposed that the attachment system becomes integrated as an aspect of personality, the emphasis of the theory is on interpersonal behavior and its representation. In contrast, narcissism encompasses more general self-regard and undifferentiated or merged aspects of ego organization. When pathological, narcissism addresses a "sense of self lacking sufficient inner resources to give meaning to life simply by living it fully" (Bromberg, 1986, p. 441). Nevertheless, looking at adult attachment relationships without reference to narcissism may obscure how attachment patterns are related to esteem and self-protection. It's to this end that M. Carole Pistole argues that insecure attachment is characterised by a greater degree of narcissistic vulnerability than secure attachment. Concomitantly, preoccupied and avoidant attachment reflect different strategies for managing vulnerability and self-esteem.

Narcissistic vulnerability affects the management of adults' love relationships (Elson, 1987; Solomon, 1989), because the person needs to obtain self-functions from the environment. Relationships that are not driven by narcissistic vulnerability involve a mutuality in which the focus on the self is balanced by a solid, attuned and healthy dependence on the other held in recognition of another as a separate, autonomous self (Solomon, 1989). The self is solid enough that the partner is intellectually and emotionally experienced as different and separate from self (i.e., with separate interests and desires), while also being affectively attuned through the mirco-affective ties of pair bonding, love investment, and mutuality in current and future focus and conflict resolution.

Research indicates that secure attachment relationships demonstrate a sense of self and the partner as a separate other. For example, secure attachment has been associated with more positive views of others (Collins & Read, 1990; Hazan & Shaver, 1987), interdependence (Simpson, 1990), intimacy (Bartholomew & Horowitz, 1991; Levy & Davis, 1988), trust (Feeney & Noller, 1990; Hazan & Shaver, 1987), and mutuality (Feeney & Noller, 1991). Securely attached adults have reported "being able to accept and support the partner despite the partner's faults" (Hazan & Shaver, 1987, p. 515); and in describing their relationships, they "emphasise the importance of openness and closeness . .. while at the same time seeking to retain their individual identity" (Feeney & Noller, 1991, p. 208). The picture that emerges of secure attachment includes an appreciation of both self and other as well as a capacity for openness and cooperativeness. This description is consistent with others being perceived as separate people and with esteem being distributed between self and other.

It is from this position that we come to see the way that the insecure strategies are constructed to obscure a view of the other as other.

More narcissistically based relationships are characterised by the needs of the self assuming a primary importance. The self is more fragile, and esteem is more difficult to manage internally—that is, there exists a greater degree of narcissistic vulnerability (Solomon, 1989). The person is more sensitive to emotional injury, focuses attention more on personal needs than on the partner, and expects partner to behave in affirming and self-enhancing ways. Interactions with the partner are often dictated by the need to stabilise a sense of worth and to regulate feelings, especially negative feelings about self (see Kinston, 1987).

As noted above, more narcissistically vulnerable persons, in adapting, organize defensive structures (i.e., patterns "of thoughts, feelings, and behaviours"; Patton & Robbins, 1982, p. 880) that attempt to cover over or compensate for the vulnerability and thereby protect the self. Rather than regulating esteem needs through an internal self-confirming process, self-regard is accomplished through a pattern of approaching (e.g., merging; Kohut & Wolf, 1978) or distancing from (Akhtar & Thomson, 1982) significant others. The other person's importance stems more from bolstering or maintaining the self and less from an appreciation of the other in his or her separateness (i.e., likeness and "differentness") from self.




Avoidant Attachment Systems

So the avoidant attachment system manages narcissistic vulnerability through distancing from the partner, thereby, avoiding closeness and intimacy (Bartholomew & Horowitz, 1991; Hazan & Shaver, 1987). These relationships are associated with low levels of relying on others, using others as a safe base, romantic involvement (Bartholomew & Horowitz, 1991), self-disclosure (Bartholomew & Horo- witz, 1991; Mikulincer & Nachshon, 1991), intensity (Bartholomew, 1990; Feeney & Noller, 1990), and higher separation distress than the securely attached (Mikulincer et al., 1990). Further, affect is regulated through dismissing the importance of attachment (Bartholomew & Horo- witz, 1991), dismissing distress (Kobak & Sceery, 1988), directing attention toward nonemotional domains (e.g., work; Hazan & Shaver, 1990), and idealizing self or other (Hazan & Shaver, 1987). The need to wall off or reject a portion of experience (e.g., intense feelings and emotional experiences, especially of distress) is indicative of narcissistic vulnerability and a need for partner's cooperation in managing self. Because self-regard is based "on the ability to temporarily tolerate negative affects in order to achieve mastery over threatening or frustrating situations" (Cassidy & Kobak, 1988, p. 304), the defensive function of avoidant strategies leaves the self-structure still vulnerable. An additional indication of narcissistic vulnerability in avoidant attachment comes from the functioning of anger in relationships. "Anger and hostility are often instigated by threats to self-esteem of an interpersonal nature" (Kernis, Grannemann, & Barclay, 1989, p. 1013). Perhaps the hostility associated with avoidant attachment (Bartholomew & Horowitz, 1991; Kobak & Sceery, 1988) is triggered as a self-protective mechanism that (a) defends against anxiety and negative feelings about self or (b) function to repair damaged self-esteem and preserve a feeling of well-being (Kerni ; et al.( 1989; Solomon, 1989). Self-defense in the relationship is also suggested by the avoidantly attached person's endorsement of love as friendship in the absence of a corresponding endorsement of romantic love, passion, commitment, or satisfaction (see Feeney & Noller, 1990, 1991; Hazan & Shaver, 1987; Lily & Davis, 1988). The endorsement of friendship can be interpreted as a means of maintaining safer levels of emotional intensity, which is consistent with a more fragile self-structure and with using a defensive style rather than internal resources to regulate esteem.

In a seeming contradiction to this argument, like the securely attached and unlike fearful avoidants, dismissing avoidants have reported high self esteem and self-acceptance (Bartholomew & Horowitz, 1991). The uniquely high, positive evaluation of self was coupled with a uniquely low leve of subjective distress and with interpersonal problems characterised by hostility and coldness (Bartholomew & Horowitz, 1991). This constellation of findings, interpreted in conjunction with directing attention away from distress (Kobak & Sceery, 1988) and dismissing attachment needs (Bartholomew & Horowitz, 1991), can be construed as indicating a defensively bolstered self. Meaningful self-worth would be accompanied by competence in relationship and affect management (Basch, 1988), which is associated with secure but not dismissing attachment.

In sum, the primary characteristic of avoidant attachment is avoidance of closeness and ensuing intimacy. The defensive strategy creates a sort of safety in the perceived "detachment" from the partner. Distance facilitates cutting off or never being "touched" by perceived criticism or the experience of intense emotions and, thereby, protects a fragile self from being emotionally overwhelmed with unmanageable emotion. Similarly, the stance of detachment functions to keep away from the self-structure "anything that would diminish it" (Akhtar & Thomson, 1982, p. 13). For instance, by distancing, fearful avoidant people hold at bay their fear of intimacy, possible rejection, and the self's being overwhelmed with unmanageable emotion (see Bartholomew, 1990). Similarly, the high self-concept of dismissing avoidance can be construed as an idealisation of self. Distancing from emotional closeness with partner helps ensure that the facade is not punctured, self-esteem is not injured, and unmanageable emotion is not exprerienced. In avoidant attachment, the person protects self against the dangerousness of others (Kinston, 1987). It is as if the persons' "fragile sense of self will disintegrate" (Modell, 1986, p. 299) or be emotionally overwhelmed or swallowed up (see Kohut & Wolf, 1978) if the partners get close or if feelings are intense.


Preoccupied Attachment Systems.

Preoccupied attachment can be construed as a defensive strategy in which narcissistic vulnerability is managed through merger with the partner. In research, preoccupied romantic relationships were characterised by high levels of idealising the partner and an extreme approach to love which includes obsessive preoccupation (Peer ey & Noller, 1990; Hazan & Shaver, 1987), hyper-vigilance to separation, greater distress over separation (Mikulincer et al., 1990), and attending to distress (Kobak & Sceery, 1988). These characteristics indicate more intensity in attention to partner than is required for interdependency and intimacy (see Elson, 1987), which indeed are not so well accomplished in preoccupied attachment. In addition, the strong clinging and idealised focus on partner is consistent with gaining affirmation through merger - that is, experiencing the idealized other, who contains worth and value, as if he or she were a part of self, were a selfobject.

Moreover, although subtle, language also indicates fusion with the partner. In one study, persons with a preoccupied attachment exhibited a higher level of couple references ("we" vs. "I") associated with the perception of problems in the relationship (Feeney & Noller, 1991). Only when there were problems (i.e., incongruence between self and partner) is a "we" (two people) versus an "I" (fusion) recognised.

Other relationship characteristics also suggest that a component of neediness directs the relationship behaviors. Studies have found that preoccupied attachment is characterised by more emotional dependence, a desire for more commitment (Feeney & Noller, 1990), greater reliance on the partner, more use of others as a safe base (Bartholomew & Horowitz, 1991), and inappropriately high levels of self-disclosure (Mikulincer & Nachshon, 1991). Further, persons with a preoccupied attachment experience more emotional ups and downs within the relationship (Hazan & Shaver, 1987). In sum, they seem to "depend on others to maintain positive self regard" (Bartholomew & Horowitz, 1991, p. 234). The interpretation of clinging preoccupation as a defensive strategy is supported by other research. Preoccupied attachment has been associated with lower levels of esteem (Collins & Read, 1990; Feeney & Noller, 1990), and research indicates that low self-esteem persons use interpersonal behaviour "to enhance their self-affect" (Baumgardner, Kaufman, & Levy, 1989, p. 919).

A key function of the preoccupied strategy is to maintain an openness of one's perceived hurt in order for the other to receive empathic attunement to the sense of insecurity this perception induces (Mikulincer & Nachshon, 1991). This 'log of claims' approach is perceived as a way of restoring the connection to security, and, because of the proclivity to not seeing the other outside of the fusion need, blinds the peroccupied to the avoidance of the avoidant partner. This is the genesis of the pursuit-withdrawal dynamic (Mikulincer et al., 1990).


Looking at attachment through the lens of narcissistic vulnerability stimulates making a distinction between appropriate security needs and narcissistic use of the partner to manage self and avoid being hurt. In preoccupied attachment, the defensive strategy is to merge with an idealised other who bolsters feelings of worth. In avoidant attachment, the partner is distanced to maintain self through a behavioral or phenomenological response that strictly avoids closeness and any ensuing intense or negative feelings. One avoidant strategy keeps the self contained, closed, passive, and nonassertive; the other strategy protects through idealizing the self and discounting the importance of the attachment system.

While Pistole's research is predominantly about how healthy personalities navigate narcissistic vulnerability issues, she also points to the attachment-based precursors to psychopathology. For example, fearful avoidance corresponds closely to avoidant personality disorder (Bartholomew, 1990), and dismissing avoidance is reminiscent of narcissistic personality disorder. The high, defensive self-concept of dismissing attachment is similar to the idealized, narcissistic grandiose self; both patterns involve latent vulnerability, coldness, hostility, and using others (American Psychiatric Association, 1987; Kernberg, 1984). Moreover, Mikulincer and Shaver go to great lengths to point out the vulnerability to borderline states in those with preoccupied strategies.

The attachment connection with narcissistic vulnerability seems key in the processing of adult attachment issues both in the contained dyad and intrapersonally. A range of the abovementoined references note that with relationship issues, therapists can facilitate clients' progress by defining and validating attachment needs and also clarifying how narcissistic needs related to self-regard, self-esteem management, and ego organisation are compromising the fundamental mix of autonomy and intimacy which characterises a thriving and life-affirming secure attachment.



http://www.thepresentparticiple.blogspot.com

3 comments:

xochicasa said...

This is very helpful to me. I am on a path to understand where I stand in regards to my preoccupied attachment, I suspected issues relating to narcissism , and found little on the subject. Thank you. Would like to correspond via email and share thoughts.

Anonymous said...

Could you site the M. Carole Pistole article you are referring to? It sounds like a very helpful perspective.
Thanks!

Luke said...

Adult attachment style and narcissistic vulnerability.
Pistole, M. Carole
Psychoanalytic Psychology, Vol 12(1), 1995, 115-126. doi: 10.1037/h0079603
Special Section: Contemporary Structural Psychoanalysis and Relational Psychoanalysis.

http://www.slideshare.net/veropabon/narcissism-and-vulnerability


http://psycnet.apa.org/journals/pap/12/1/115/